Good day for Kiwis at Super 14 judiciary

20th April 2009, 14:45 WST


Highlanders captain Jimmy Cowan has received no further punishment for his contentious tackle, capping a perfect day for New Zealand players in front of the Super 14 rugby judiciary.

All Blacks halfback Cowan faced an automatic judicial hearing in Wellington today after being sent off for a late and dangerous tackle on Blues first five-eighth Jimmy Gopperth in Friday's match in Auckland.
Sanzar judicial officer Bruce Squire found the tackle to be neither late nor dangerous, deeming the red card from Australian referee Stuart Dickinson sufficient punishment.
Video footage showed the tackle was made less than a second after Gopperth had kicked the ball, Squire said in a statement, while the point of contact was at Gopperth's chest level.
Cowan's only failure was not using his arms to make the tackle, but it was “no more serious than tackles of a similar kind which are routinely met with penalty kicks or, in extreme cases, a yellow card”.
Earlier, Chiefs players Richard Kahui and James McGougan both survived charges of dangerous play emanating from their defeat of the Cheetahs in Kimberley.
Prop James McGougan was cited for alleged trampling while centre Richard Kahui was cited for a dangerous “spear” tackle.
McGougan pleaded guilty to the trampling, which was penalised at the time by referee Nathan Pearce, and judicial officer Jannie Lubbe issued a reprimand and decided to take no further action.
Kahui pleaded not guilty and Lubbe said a review of new evidence found there was no lifting of the Cheetahs player and driving of him into the ground.
NZPA

http://www.thewest.com.au/default.as...ntentID=137052

That was a nasty shoulder at Gopperth and he's the captain for Pete's sake, he's not supposed to do that stuff! A red was harsh at the time but I don't think a suspension would have been uncalled for...

Good decision on Cowan, no way was that late!

I agree. Should've been a yellow card at worst. Cowan's case probably wasn't helped by having been a typically gobby half-back & Aussie Stu wanted 20mins of peace & quiet!

Thank God, I wouldn't want to beat the Highlanders without him on the field