Maybe ... Maybe Not.

Printable View

04-03-23, 18:48
fulvio sammut

Maybe ... Maybe Not.

So RugbyWA decree that relegation/promotion will depend on some kind of adjustment between first, second, and third grade.

That presupposes that the top 11 clubs have three grades.

I have my doubts.

Associates and Wanneroo were unable to field third grade teams without relying heavily on their firsts and seconds doubling up today and I am informed Wests, Kalamunda and Cottesloe are in the same boat or worse.

Will this brain fart be reviewed, or will these clubs be allowed to nominate teams and then forfeit week after week, just so RugbyWA can save face? And what benefit is there in other clubs having to deal with constant regular forfeits? Great way to lose player interest, boys!

Must say though that Wanneroo and Associates have quality first grade teams on the basis of today's performances.
04-03-23, 19:37
wholetruth

Finally, some pre-season gossip.
I hear most club numbers are down but it's an early start this year and some are waiting for their imports to arrive.
I hope it's not like the "old days" when to be a Premier Grade club you nominated Colts and then surprise, surprise you didn't have one.
What I don't understand under the new requirements is how a club (did I say UWA?) will be able to qualify for Premier Grade without juniors - based on last season - which is a prerequisite for being in Premier Grade this year or so I am led to believe.
Anyone help me here.
04-03-23, 20:19
fulvio sammut

I think you may have hit upon something there, WT.

Something to do with self interest in all its manifestations.

And looking after that interest no matter the consequences to inconsequential clubs.
05-03-23, 07:28
GIGS20

Maybe a team that doesn't field a side in a grade for one week receives 0 relegation points that week, a club that doesn't field a side in a grade all season receives -2 relegation points with all other relegation points matching competition points.

You could even have a multiplier for the grades you must field to be in prem grade.

Therefore if uni don't field a junior team all season they receive -3 points per round for that.

The top second division team will likely then compete on an even playing field if they field all teams.

You could also have some mechanism that reduces relegation points for players who've already played a game that day, but that would be hard to police.
10-03-23, 21:32
fulvio sammut

I've just seen on Palmyra's facebook page that they are playing the Force at McGillivray at 11am tomorrow in a pre season game.

I trust it's the Force Academy, not the Force itself, or the outcome might be embarrassing for Palmyra. Or maybe not.

Why the morning start? Why at McGillivray?

Or is this in preparation for April !?

.
15-03-23, 10:45
Hansie

Hallo Fulvio, Long time...
I have been O/S generating business to fund our Submarines.
O.K. so which club has poached players from which other club? Who has spent the first 367 billion on imports?
Who will win the Premiership?
15-03-23, 12:09
fulvio sammut

Hi Hansie,

Like yourself, I've been substantially away from this site and rugby for a few years now, until I made a passing visit a month or so ago.

Not hooked, but passably amused. Retirement does that to you.

The situation among clubs doesn't seem to have changed much. Same shit, varying levels.

I'll probably take up pickle ball. Pretty big among geriatrics and cruisers in America, apparently.

Cheers.
15-03-23, 12:23
fulvio sammut

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hansie

I
Who has spent the first 367 billion on imports?
Who will win the Premiership?

Answer A: Twiggy Forrest
Answer B: Not Twiggy Forrest
15-03-23, 13:47
Rugaree

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hansie

Hallo Fulvio, Long time...

Who will win the Premiership?

Far too early to call, as Ryan Westaway said "you don't win a premiership in the first 6 rounds". Last year Wests only made finals with a last minute try against Wanneroo.

It'll come down to injuries and strength in depth and no doubt a few panicked imports to bolster the ranks of the big boys
15-03-23, 19:00
westies man

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rugaree

Far too early to call, as Ryan Westaway said "you don't win a premiership in the first 6 rounds". Last year Wests only made finals with a last minute try against Wanneroo.

It'll come down to injuries and strength in depth and no doubt a few panicked imports to bolster the ranks of the big boys

Pray tell Rugareeth whom is this Rhianna Westaway ye speak off and what doth she know about winning rugbyeth and have they fornicated offspring to be victorious in heat of battle
16-03-23, 08:15
GIGS20

Quote:

Originally Posted by westies man

Pray tell Rugareeth whom is this Rhianna Westaway ye speak off and what doth she know about winning rugbyeth and have they fornicated offspring to be victorious in heat of battle

Started the carton early last night aye Westie?
16-03-23, 08:51
shasta

Quote:

Originally Posted by GIGS20

Started the carton early last night aye Westie?

I dunno about that; but this Ryan/Rihanna has a lot to answer for if he/she is truly the sauce of that worn out cliché. Under-pressure coaches have used that one to deflect questions for centuries. I think Brain Dead Dick had it on speed dial.
16-03-23, 10:56
GIGS20

Quote:

Originally Posted by shasta

I dunno about that; but this Ryan/Rihanna has a lot to answer for if he/she is truly the sauce of that worn out cliché. Under-pressure coaches have used that one to deflect questions for centuries. I think Brain Dead Dick had it on speed dial.

Are you talking about the fornicated offspring line?

I don't know that I'd be too impressed with somebody who fornicates with their own offspring, but they might do things differently at Wests
16-03-23, 11:04
Rugaree

Quote:

Originally Posted by westies man

Pray tell Rugareeth whom is this Rhianna Westaway ye speak off and what doth she know about winning rugbyeth and have they fornicated offspring to be victorious in heat of battle

NO
16-03-23, 17:17
wholetruth

A few preview stories on RugbyWA's website this year. Hope they keep it going.
I'm hearing most clubs are down on numbers. Maybe the early start.
Anyone else heard anything?
16-03-23, 18:07
shasta

Quote:

Originally Posted by GIGS20

Are you talking about the fornicated offspring line?

I don't know that I'd be too impressed with somebody who fornicates with their own offspring, but they might do things differently at Wests

I'm not too sure where that has anything to do with a very old coach's cliche, so I'll leave that well alone.
24-04-23, 20:04
PeterBrodbec

It is important for rugby clubs to support junior participation as this gives players the opportunity to develop their skills and experience. If clubs are consistently unable to field teams of this stature, this can lead to a decrease in player interest and ultimately affect the quality of sport in the region.
25-04-23, 18:29
bootsetal06

A shout out to the coaches and players of the two young kids teams that played at half time this weekend. They had a great grasp of the fundamentals and their tackling and running was refreshing to watch and enjoyable too . WELL DONE and keep it up !
26-04-23, 13:47
PeterBrodbec

Yes, it really is a valuable experience for young teams to play in front of a large audience. "Make way for the young."