0
![Not allowed!](images/buttons/down_dis.png)
![Not allowed!](images/buttons/up_dis.png)
Ok so now we finally have the team that was supposed to run onto the paddock in round one... we have a bit of a conundrum. Some of our second string lads have really stood up and are putting pressure on the run-on team
So how do you think it will look come Saturday??
1)Pek Cowan
2)Ben Whittaker
3)Tim Fairbrother
4)Tom Hockings
5)Nathan Sharpe
6)Matt Hodgson
7)Dave Pocock
8)Richard Brown
9)Brett Sheehan
10)Dave Hill
11)Nick Cummins
12)James O'Connor
13)Ryan Cross
14)Mitch Inman
15)Cam Sheperd
16) Matt Dunning
17) Sam Wykes
18) Ben McCalman
19) Justin Turner
20) Mark Bartolomeusz
21) Sam Harris
22) Dane Haylett Petty
Im not sure if we'll go 4 forwards 3 backs on the bench given the tough opposition.. but i was thinking that with Matt covering 1,2 & 3, Sam W covering 4, 5, 6, 7 & 8 with Mcalman covering 4, & 5 and at a push 6 wheras Barto and DHP can cover 10, 11, 14 and 15 and Sam H can cover 12 & 13 and JT 9
I just do not know what Mitch is going to do with the half-back situation Turner must get a go but COY played brilliantly
I am not to sure if Sheehan is going to deliver the goods. I would give him one more week rest
I say go with COY for 50 min and then play Turner for the rest of the game. Turner's unpredictability might just be what we need against the Blues in the last half hour.
Rabbit to 15 and shift everybody up one to make him fit......Cross has been toilet at 13 and barely serviceable at 12, Inman will fit anywhere ATM.
I'd be inclined to go three backs, with Dane losing out and bring another flanker on. They're going to be working overtime in cover and at the breakdown and it'd be nice to have our world class backrow thinking they could have a rest if they need it!
C'mon the![]()
![]()
Tenner says Dunning and Fairbrother start. Back in 2008 (?) when Dunning was with the Tahs him and the other two absolutely handed it to the Blues. We need to starve them of ball and that means beating them in the scrum (praying that Woodcock and Afoa and the other injured dude stay out).
I don't reckon Shep is ready to go back to 15 yet either. So I would wager the same backline except Nick Cummins in for Bartholomeusz who will take DHPs bench spot. Keep COY and Turner as well.
Smoke me a kipper, I'll be back for breakfast.
Henderson to start - nice and rested .
was reading somewhere today that Sheehan and Staners are still out this week.
Yeah knew Stanners was still out wasnt sure about Sheehan.
I spoke to one of the RugbyWA guys a few weeks ago when they came to do a kids clinic at Bayswater and he said its not just Sheehans Hammies that are playing up but also his lower back which he Injured in 2008 playing for the Tahs.
If thats the Case then the Same lineup at 9 as last week is the Go, turner will give that extra spark needed when the team is tiring at about 60 mins...
I agree with Pieter about the Sheehan/O'Young/Turner situation, especially if Sheehan isn't 100%. Turner is still a young kid and should be used from the bench, just as Rabbit was (from what I recall). Let's not load him up with the expectation of being the second coming of Gregan just yet!
Also agree with GIGS about Rabbit at full-back. 12 is his best position, but 15 is where he fits into the current team the best.
As to the subs, I'd still prefer 4 forwards, and neither Dunning nor Pek are proven as hookers, whilst Castle's looked good so far. However, if Henderson is fit and Pek's been working on his throws, he and Pek on the bench with a front row of (I can't believe I'm saying this): Dunning, Whittaker, Fairbrother. Wykes and McCalman can cover the locks/back row with a bit of switching round.
The subs for the backs would then be: Turner, Bart, Harris, with Turner covering 9, Harris the centres and Bart everyone else.
I guess that makes my team:
1. Dunning
2. Whittaker
3. Fairbrother
4. Hocking
5. Sharpe
6. Hodgo
7. Pocock
8. Brown
9. O'Young
10. Hill
11. Cummins
12. Cross
13. Inman
14. Shepherd
15. O'Connor
16. Cowan
17. Henderson
18. Wykes
19. McCalman
20. Turner
21. Bart
22. Harris
Last edited by Sheikh; 13-04-10 at 13:02.
JO'C will want to play at 15. Quade Cooper is untouchable as the Wallabies fly-half and short of injury will be engraved in the team sheet. That leaves Giteau and Barnes to tussle for the 12 jersey. If JO'C wants game time with the Wallabies it will be at 15 or from the bench where he could cover 10/12/15.
Smoke me a kipper, I'll be back for breakfast.
I wouldnt mind seeing a bench with Turner, Bart and DHP sitting on it. Bart can cover the centres and flyhalf if need be. DHP can cover the abck three. I am still not a huge fan of Harris. He played pretty well against the Landers sure, but he is a stop gap player at best, and playing both he and Bart is not going to help the likes of DHP.
I also would like to see Inman in the team. I think he is playing very well, and deserves to be there, so a centre combo of Cross and Inman would be nice. But what do we do when Spanner comes back? Drop Cross? Drop Inman? Drop Cummins?
I guess these are the selection dilemmas that coachs pray for though, so it cant be bad!
Ditto
---------- Post added at 16:22 ---------- Previous post was at 16:18 ----------
Sheehan may have to wait to SA for his return... been saying all along how good Turner is..... Keep the backline as it is PB.... WHY CHANGE A WINNING FORMULA. Cummins may get the nod over Batho..... just through his direct running and unpredicability
Smoke me a kipper, I'll be back for breakfast.
I think the Force should go in with exactly the same team except Nick Cummins should come onto the bench and Haylett-Pety be dropped. I'll probably give Inman another run and hopefully he performs alot better than in recent matches.
I'm not a big fan of Inman, he doesn't offer much in attack, I don't think he has broken the line once this year. He has been given alot of opportunities this year and hasn't really performed.
I haven't been keeping a close enough ear/eye on the news this week and only saw the match this morning...finally... so assume nothing came of Pek's right hook?
Assuming his (and everyone else's) availability I would reward endevour and go with the same 22.
"Bloody oath we did!"
Nathan Sharpe, Legend.
Sorry - not yet a fan of DHP. His time will come but it's not now.
If Cummins is fit then DHP drops out. That's an easy choice imho.